Philanthropisms

David Conrad-Pérez: The Triangle Shirtwaist fire & the origins of modern charity

• Rhodri Davies • Season 1 • Episode 119

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 1:00:06

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode of the Philanthropisms podcast we talk to historian and former journalist David Conrad-Pérez, about his new book Fire in the Heart of the City: The Triangle Shirtwaist Tragedy and the Origins of Modern Charity, and what the modern philanthropy sector can learn from a pivotal moment in early C20th New York history. Including:

  • How did the book come about?
  • What can philanthropy practitioners can learn from it? 
  • How did Adolf Ochs come to be editor of the New York Times, and how did this shape his attitudes towards wealth and charity?
  • Why was the Triangle Shirtwaist factory already a focal point for protest and debate?
  • What role had Ochs and the New York Times played in framing public perceptions of striking workers?
  • How and why did some wealthy women in New York become supporters of the labor movement?
  • Was their genuine solidarity between these wealthy supporters and workers, or was the relationship only ever an uneasy one?
  • How did the fire at the Triangle Shirtwaist factory happen?
  • What was the public reaction to the fire?
  • How did a court end up ruling that the factory owners were not culpable for the fire, and what was the reaction to this verdict?
  • To what extent was the charitable response to the tragedy, promoted by the NYT and others, motivated by a desire to head-off calls for more radical reform?
  • Was Ochs’s decision to push the idea of a charitable response in the aftermath of the Triangle Shirtwaist fire a reflection of genuine ideological belief on his part, or more down to a pragmatic realisation that this would play better with the wealthy business elites on whose support he relied?
  • What was “scientific charity”, and how widespread was the idea at the time of the fire?
  • What role did the New York Charity Organization Society play in promoting these ideas? 
  • In the aftermath of the fire, how were principles of scientific charity used to justify not providing support to immigrant communities?
  • How did the Times’s “One Hundred Neediest Cases” campaign come about following the fire, and what role did this go on to play in shaping ideas of charity in the US?
  • How were the ideas of scientific charity linked to those of eugenics?
  • What value do you think a historical perspective can bring to philanthropists, funders and non-profit professionals?
  • Are there limits to the utility of historical comparison in understanding the present? What should we take into account or be aware of? 


Further Resources: