Philanthropisms
Philanthropisms is the podcast that puts philanthropy in context. Through conversations with expert guests and deep dives into topics, host Rhodri Davies explores giving throughout history, the key trends shaping generosity around the world today and what the future might hold for philanthropy. Contact: rhodri@whyphilanthropymatters.com.
Philanthropisms
David Conrad-Pérez: The Triangle Shirtwaist fire & the origins of modern charity
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this episode of the Philanthropisms podcast we talk to historian and former journalist David Conrad-Pérez, about his new book Fire in the Heart of the City: The Triangle Shirtwaist Tragedy and the Origins of Modern Charity, and what the modern philanthropy sector can learn from a pivotal moment in early C20th New York history. Including:
- How did the book come about?
- What can philanthropy practitioners can learn from it?
- How did Adolf Ochs come to be editor of the New York Times, and how did this shape his attitudes towards wealth and charity?
- Why was the Triangle Shirtwaist factory already a focal point for protest and debate?
- What role had Ochs and the New York Times played in framing public perceptions of striking workers?
- How and why did some wealthy women in New York become supporters of the labor movement?
- Was their genuine solidarity between these wealthy supporters and workers, or was the relationship only ever an uneasy one?
- How did the fire at the Triangle Shirtwaist factory happen?
- What was the public reaction to the fire?
- How did a court end up ruling that the factory owners were not culpable for the fire, and what was the reaction to this verdict?
- To what extent was the charitable response to the tragedy, promoted by the NYT and others, motivated by a desire to head-off calls for more radical reform?
- Was Ochs’s decision to push the idea of a charitable response in the aftermath of the Triangle Shirtwaist fire a reflection of genuine ideological belief on his part, or more down to a pragmatic realisation that this would play better with the wealthy business elites on whose support he relied?
- What was “scientific charity”, and how widespread was the idea at the time of the fire?
- What role did the New York Charity Organization Society play in promoting these ideas?
- In the aftermath of the fire, how were principles of scientific charity used to justify not providing support to immigrant communities?
- How did the Times’s “One Hundred Neediest Cases” campaign come about following the fire, and what role did this go on to play in shaping ideas of charity in the US?
- How were the ideas of scientific charity linked to those of eugenics?
- What value do you think a historical perspective can bring to philanthropists, funders and non-profit professionals?
- Are there limits to the utility of historical comparison in understanding the present? What should we take into account or be aware of?
Further Resources:
- Buy David's book
- David's website
- David's New Republic article, "The 1915 TNR Debate That Predicted the Ills of the Billionaire Class"
- Philanthropisms podcast thematic episodes on philanthropy and social justice and philanthropy and disaster response.
- Philanthropisms podcast conversations with Annelise Hanson Shrout, Claire Dunning, Emma Saunders-Hastings, Maribel Morey and Ben Soskis.
- WPM long reads on philanthropy and the "deserving poor", and on the history of philanthropy, population debates and eugenics.
You're listening to the Philanthropists podcast with Rodri Davis. Hello, you're listening to the Philanthropisms Podcast. This is the podcast where we try to put philanthropy in context. I'm your host, Rodri Davis, And this week I'm in conversation with David Conrad Perez. Now, David is a research director at the Centre for Media and Social Impact at American University School of Communication. But more importantly, for the purposes of the podcast, and the reason he came on to talk to me is he is the author of a new book, a fascinating new book, called Fire in the Heart of the City: The Triangle Shirtwaist Tragedy and the Origins of Modern Charity. So you can probably tell from the title why I was interested. And as a fan of the history of philanthropy, I'm always keen to uh speak to people who've kind of done new research and written new books, and this was a really, really interesting one for me. So, yeah, David came on to talk about the book, and you'll hear lots more about what it's all about. It's essentially a story of early 20th century New York and the elite there, um, tied in very much with the kind of origin story of the modern New York Times, uh, and the way in which that elite responded to concerns about labour exploitation and then a very tragic um industrial fire, and used philanthropy and kind of calls for charity as a way of sort of undermining uh arguments in favour of justice and reform. So it's a really, really interesting story. So I talked to David about why it was that he'd particularly written in this book and what kind of uh brought him to it, because I often find with the history of philanthropy it's not something people necessarily start out to write, they sort of find these stories when they think they're going to look for other stories, and that was sort of a little bit the case here, um, as it often is. Um we talked about uh uh the uh figure of uh Adolf Ox, who is a very big character in the book. Um he's fascinating actually. He came to be editor of the New York Times by a very improbable series of events, um, and uh basically kind of uh turned the the New York Times into what it is today and very much kind of built its reputation and its standing within um the kind of elite society of of New York. Uh and he was instrumental in determining what became the um uh New York Times' uh 100 Needious Cases campaign, which is their sort of charitable campaign that they launched in the wake of this industrial uh fire that we'll hear about. Um so he's a really, really fascinating fascinating character and somebody I didn't really know anything about. Um we talked about the context at the time and why it was that this particular factory, the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory, was already a focal point for a lot of strike action and dissent and kind of debate. Um uh we talked about uh the the role of the labour movement and why um there were sort of so many strong calls for uh labour reform at the time and how that was sort of tied up also with concerns around immigration and some of the attitudes towards that. Um and then we talked uh about the fire itself, kind of what the context was for it, uh, and how it came about and what some of the immediate aftermath of uh of that fire was. And then we talked about the uh concept of scientific charity, which is a really important um element of the book and something I've long been fascinated by. I think there's a really interesting history there that goes back um certainly into the UK in the 19th century and then into America in the 20th, uh, and gave us many of our sort of modern ideas of kind of rational, professionalized philanthropy and charity. Uh, and these ideas were very much um kind of buzzing around at the time, and actually they were reflected in the way in which uh the uh elites within uh New York chose to respond to the fire, and particularly the way that the New York Times uh decided to frame it in its 100 needest cases. Um and David has some really interesting arguments about kind of why those decisions were taken uh and kind of what some of the long-standing impacts were. Uh, and he also touches on the way in which um there's a really unfortunate history of that scientific charity overlapping with kind of early 20th century interest in eugenics as well, um, which is something I've also long been fascinated in. Um and then David also uh and I also had a really interesting conversation sort of more widely about what uh he thinks the uh the value of historical perspective is in terms of informing current practice and what some of the kind of benefits and also the limitations of that are. So without further ado, let's go into the conversation. I really enjoyed this one, as I'm sure you'll be able to tell. It was really fascinating to hear about this piece of history that I didn't really know anything about, but really kind of touched on lots of issues that I am very interested in. So I hope you all really enjoy it too. Um without further ado, let's get into it and I will be back at the end for the usual bit of housekeeping. I'm here with David Conrad Perez. Hi there, David.
SPEAKER_01Hi. Great to have you on the
SPEAKER_00podcast. Um, and as people will probably know from listening to the intro, um, the reason you're here is to talk about a new book that you've got out. Uh the book's called Fire in the Heart of the City, uh, The Triangle Shirtwaist Tragedy and the Origins of Modern Charity. So uh the clue is certainly there in terms of the mention of charity about why we're here talking about it on this podcast. Um, but it I think it'll be really interesting for lots of people because it's probably a story that many people don't know, and it's a really fascinating one. It's not one that I actually knew at all, despite the fact I'm quite a big nerd about the history of charity. So I'm really looking forward to kind of digging into it. Um, maybe the best place to start is for you to just kind of give a headline summary of what the book's about and and why you wrote it.
SPEAKER_01Yes, absolutely. And and thank you again for for this opportunity. I'm such a a fan of all the the thoughtful, smart work you bring to this field. So it's great to be here. Um yeah, and you know, I feel like I I can probably give a um because your program's focused on philanthropy, I think I can probably give a fuller answer to this than I'm usually able to give. Um, because it, I mean, it started with a bit of a sort of charity mystery story, I'd say. So I was, you know, I was working on the book. It started a little more than a decade ago. It just came out a couple months ago. And um at the time I was living in New York, I was a PhD student studying the history of philanthropy. And I was also working full-time in public media at a program called On the Media. And I came across this rather sort of obscure charity arrangement that uh I'd say probably merged these two worlds. Um, and it was something called the 100 Neadiest Cases Fund. And it's a campaign that the New York Times does every year. Um, they still do it, it raises you know millions of dollars for a handful of charities. And they've been doing this for more than a century, since 1912. And so it's the oldest arrangement that we have in the history of the US of this kind of media charity partnership. And so I had you know the basic question of a, I guess, a doctoral student back then, which was how did it start? Um, you know, what was its origin? And if you read the pages of the Times, it has a rather neat story that it tells. And uh, you know, the the quick summary of it is essentially the the publisher back then um in 1911, um, his name was Adolf Ox. The story goes that he went for a big um, or if he went for a lone walk after having a big, you know, Christmas Day dinner. And on that walk, he came across a New Yorker in need outside of a YMCA. And he gave that person a little bit of money and a job in the Times distribution department, and then he felt so good about that act of generosity afterwards that he wanted to spread that feeling to the rest of New York. And so he created this um this charity campaign. And, you know, as these things go, it's it's a neat little story. Um, but if you're a history of that era, um, whether it's of of philanthropy or of New York, there's a lot of um holes in that kind of story. And so I decided to um to you know go to the archives and um see if I could find anything that Ox had ever written or said that supported that story. And um, you know, I'm sure we'll talk about him a little bit, but he had a very long career in journalism and he always pointed to this charity campaign as his proudest achievement. And but he and so he spoke about it, you know, relatively frequently, but he never told this story. And so um I spoke to members of the Times Publishing Family and eventually learned that that it came about, you know, in the 1980s because the the campaign, it was the 75th anniversary of the campaign, and they needed an origin story. And so somebody in the family provided this one and they they kind of went with it ever since. And I I think that's probably a familiar tale of other of other charities too, who at some point they're like, Oh, it would really, really nice to have a story. So they organize around one, and and this is the one that they organized around. And so, um, so you know, at this point I knew pretty with with even more certainty that this was likely not the full story. And so um, you know, the book sort of started by for me was was just digging deeper, seeing what was el what else was happening in New York at this time, what was Ox writing about, what was the Times writing about at this time, and eventually that led me to the the triangle fire um in New York into um telling a a bigger story than had been told before about that that event um and the Times plays a central part of
SPEAKER_00it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah,
SPEAKER_00absolutely, and it's a really fascinating story. And I, you know, as I say, I didn't really know anything about the the triangle chipways factory fire. Um, obviously it's kind of an important event in New York history, um, but just not one that I was familiar with. Um and we'll come on to that in a moment. I just I want before we get there, just to kind of talk a little bit more about this character of Adolf Fox, because he, again, not somebody I was familiar with as a historical figure, but just absolutely fascinating. Um he's a key figure in the story that you tell in the book. Can you just say a little bit more about how it was that he came to be editor of the New York Times? Because I think that backstory was just blew me away, and I think is really kind of important in understanding the role that he ended up ended up playing in terms of the response to this tragedy and how that kind of shaped his uh influence over charity.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, of course. It's a great question. I think um, yeah, and I'd say that understanding, you know, the New York Times is really key to this whole history. And the traditionally, you know, the New York Times has been uh has been used by historians, I think, as the paper of record, so a way of describing, you know, details of what happened on the day of the fire. Um, but they're really an actor in this history. And to understand the Times, you really have to understand Adolf Ochs, who is the the publisher who basically created the modern New York institution that we have today. And he is somebody who, you know, a lot of, you know, maybe a lot of people haven't heard about the fire, but I think a lot fewer have heard about Ox. Um, you know, there's statues to him in the Times building today, but not a lot of journalists know much about him. You know, even among journalism historians, you know, we often talk about people like Ralph Pulitzer and um William Randolph Hearst in the history of US journalism, but um, it was Ox who actually created the modern New York Times we have today and put their star papers both out of business um within his lifetime. And, you know, the current publisher of the New York Times is his great-great-grandson, and it's always been a relative of his ever since he he purchased the paper in 1896. And, you know, as a side note, it's always been um a man. Part of Ox's, you know, background was was more than being a product of his time, he was um he was quite sexist. He never hired a woman reporter or editor. Um he never believed that women had the right to vote even after they earned the right to vote. He kind of built into the institution of the times that it would always go to one of his relatives, but you know, he only had one child and was a daughter. And so he wasn't gonna leave the newspaper to his daughter, so he left it to her um her husband, who is the Salzberger, and it's been sort of along that line ever since. And but you know, without getting on too much of a detour, I mean, this that fact connects to the book because we're talking about the women's labor movement. So when you know a little bit about, you know, his own biases, you can um it's not so surprising why the the Times covered the labor movement the way that it did. But um, but to stay on on track with your question, you know, he had he had quite a backstory. And I think, you know, some of that backstory helps answer, you know, why and how he he purchased the New York Times and how he he turned it into the paper that it was. You know, he arrived in New York at 38 and he was a total outsider back then. And he was somebody who had been an outsider, you know, for most of his life. He grew up in poverty first in Ohio and then in a shock in Tennessee. And he grew up watching the the mistakes of his father, who was a very ambitious man, but he failed multiple times in trying to start his own businesses. And so from the time, you know, that he was a kid, Ox was determined to be the one who changed his family's fortune and to kind of break the pattern of his father. And he came to believe that buying the New York Times was his way to do that. And at this point in 1896, he was already the publisher of uh a pretty good Southern newspaper called the Chattanooga Times, but he was also massively in debt. I mean, he was he arrived in New York about a half million dollars in debt, which is uh, you know, a lot of money today, but you can imagine how much that was back then. And so, you know, the book takes you into the sort of midnight scheming sessions um that he does with another disgruntled Times reporter who's trying to help him and it follows him as he hustles from bank to bank for loans. He would use this sort of uh gold trim checkbook that he would flash around at meetings to make it seem like he had a lot of money. But we know from the archives that he actually had a Tennessee creditor open up that account for him on borrowed money with the promise that he wouldn't actually touch it, but he could just at least get the checkbook. So he would use these kind of tricks to make it seem like he was a man of money because who would, you know, who would have a checkbook like that if he didn't have money? And but it was, you know, it was Ox. And the point is that he made it happen. So he ended up meeting the right people, especially a banker named Jacob Schiff, who was sort of uh on the level of Rockefeller and Carnegie as the sort of modern archetype of the philanthropy of the you know the new philanthropist. And he becomes more important around the time of the fire and really helps Ox, you know, convince the other stockholders of the Times to sell the paper to him. And and he does it. You know, he bought the newspaper for 70, about $75,000, all loans without a penny of his own money. And then, you know, what happened next was the great business turnaround stories in US history. It was he took the Times from the 14th most popular newspaper in New York to becoming a world leader. And his strategy was simple. You know, instead of chasing headlines, he chased credibility. So he what he knew he couldn't compete with the circulation of the Hearst and the Pulitzers. So he wanted to compete with their character. And he built uh a newspaper specifically for New York's wealthiest families, and he built its brand around it being a clean newspaper that you could, you know, leave on your kitchen table for everyone to read in the family. And he used that strategically as a language to attract advertising money. So he convinced uh department store owners like the Strauss family behind Macy's that the Times went to the homes that could afford to buy shirt waists and nice clothing, you know, that Times readers weren't making shirt waists, they were buying them. Um he told railway companies, you know, that his readers could afford luxury travel. And with that strategy, he made a windfull of money, you know, more than he ever imagined, more than any of his family or peers imagined. And, you know, he went to create all these other things that we recognize today, like the New York Times Book Review, the slogan all the news that's fit to print. He moved the Times building from newspaper row at the foot of the Brooklyn Bridge to the center of Manhattan, and in doing so, he created Times Square. Um, even the ball drop, you know, that we do in the U.S. every every year was, and people think of as quintessentially New York, was actually invented by Ox. It was to celebrate the newspaper's move uptown. And so the point is that, you know, because of Ox's allegiance to the city's sort of elite families and financiers who helped him buy the paper, when the Triangle Fire happened, the Times wasn't just covering it, you know, from the outside. It was part of the story. The Times, because it was part of its brand, its editorial board, which Ox directed, had spent years attacking the immigrant workers of the Triangle shirtwaist factory who were trying to get more attention about the the unsafe conditions in that that factory and in factories across New York. And they were repeatedly dismissed by by coverage of the Times. At the height of its you
unknownknow,
SPEAKER_01biggest uprising, the the Times was s singularly responsible for taking the wind out of the strike and ending it early. And so, you know, when the when the fire happened, the the deeper story here is that the the workers of the Lower East Side, which is where the this factory was based, were not just mad at factory owners. They
unknownwere
SPEAKER_01they were angry at the New York Times because they were uniquely responsible for shaping kind of public opinion around um that time of the fire. And so, you know, when the big question facing the city back then was who was responsible and who should lead change, and Ox hijacked that moment. And he used the megaphone of the times to to declare in big head front page headlines that there was blame on both sides. You know, he urged the city to turn attention away from the workers and the of um calling for reform in the streets, and to instead, you know, support this new thing called called charity, um, which was led by the city's wealthiest philanthropists, especially Jacob Schiff, who helped him purchase the paper. So, you know, to take, you know, to simplify a rather complex story, I'd say the the wealthy circles of of New York were important because they were his readers, and charity represented the best way out of sort of a reputational crisis moment for Ox.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. And I think we'll we'll come on to that whole question there about whether, you know, the promotion of charity is the solution to society's problems, and particularly the response to something like the fire rather than the calls for justice that were being made by people within the labor movement, actually, the kind of active choice to prioritize charity, whether that was something that he believed or whether it was just a kind of pragmatic realization that that was playing into the best interests of uh the people on whom he relied for advertising and for readership. I think that's a really interesting question. I just want to cycle back to pick up on what you were saying there about the um the triangle shirtwaist uh factory itself, because we'll we'll come onto the fire in a second, but I'd just love to kind of um paint a brief picture about where things stood before the fire and why it was that the the triangle factory was already such a focal point for sort of protest and strike action and debate. What was this factory, what was it doing, and why why was it causing you know so much debate around kind of labor conditions?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so this is important, you know, because as you mentioned, the the the yeah, the factory was already at the center of a major struggle over workers' rights long before you actually get to the fire. And and I think that's a detail that uh that we've largely forgotten in remembering this history. Um the you know, the reason wasn't because the triangle owners, um, Max Blank and Isaac Harris were the only ones who were exploiting workers, um, but it was because they were, you know, one of the biggest factories at the time. They were called the shirtwaist kings. Um, and they were definitely the most vocal and aggressive in resisting the movement towards towards new fire safety protections and towards unions in the Lower East Side. You know, they hired spies um who were on the factory floor and throughout the Lower East Side of New York, and they would fire anyone who even whispered about organizing. You know, they employed people to intimidate and physically attack women who were on the picket lines um in front of their factory. And this all led them, of course, to then being the central focus of the biggest general strike by women that that had happened in the history of the country, which was called the uprising of the 20,000. And some people say it was 40,000, but you know, whether it was 20,000 people or 40,000 people, it was the biggest strike by women in the country's history. And this was in the final months of 1909 and into early 1910, so about a year before the fire took place. And the, you know, the tragic reality though is that all these efforts, you know, including that uprising, ended without the triangle factory owners ever recognizing um the two biggest demands of the strike, which were the right to unionize and the right for greater safety protections. So, you know, when the the fire happened in 1911, it wasn't as though nobody had warned New York about these problems. The and, you know, it's also true that the tragedy didn't create the struggle for reform. You know, it really exposed the sort of consequences of a struggle that workers had been um already fighting and trying to get more uh attention about um and that powerful institutions like the New York Times said had resisted for a long time.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. And and in terms of the the kind of public view of the strikers themselves and the issue as a whole at the time of the fire, what was the the kind of public attitude? Was it broadly supportive? Was it sort of split along, you know, class or wealth lines? How were people viewing the struggle of these workers?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, I'd say uh I'd say it was, I mean, quite divided, as you might imagine. Um, that's one of the, I think the fascinating things about this moment in New York's history. You know, I'd say the that the the city's uptowners, sort of the the businessmen, the newspaper editors, and the factory owners, they all viewed the strikes as uh kind of a dangerous challenge to the social order of the city. There was enormous hostility back then towards the idea of labor unions, especially labor unions consisting of women and you know, who were being associated with sort of socialism and radical politics. A lot of the the new immigrants of New York at that time were coming from from Eastern Europe, and so there was a lot of um a lot of you know noise being made in in papers like the Times that they were bringing all these dangerous ideas from Eastern Europe to the US about um anarchism and socialism and all these things when in reality they were organizing for the right to unionize, um, was sort of the biggest collective effort back then. But there was also you know a remarkable, I'd say, groundswell of support for these women from some very unexpected places. You know, one of the most surprising developments back in Then was the involvement of wealthy New York women like Ann Morgan, who was the the daughter of JP Morgan, and a woman named Alva Belmont, who is sort of often the a person's well Alva Belmont Vanderbilt, too. She was uh a Vanderbilt and then married into the Belmont family. She's often portrayed in, you know, TV shows like The Gilded Age and these other sort of period dramas from back then as this woman of immense power, and she was. And, you know, her with with Anne Morgan, they would appear on picket lines uh uh with these immigrant garment workers and they raised money that which were vital to supporting the the strike efforts. Um, because you know, if you were a worker on strike, uh you weren't getting a paycheck. And often these these women who were teenagers were the breadwinners for their family, and so um they needed some money for food, and so these sort of wealthy alliances helped them raise that money. Um, they provided legal support, um, and in some cases, you know, they were arrested themselves in the picket lines. And so, you know, many of the workers called this group the Mink Brigade because they they would show up often wearing expensive furs and even on the picket lines, and that was enough of a spectacle you can imagine that it it caught the press's attention, um, which was good because they were trying to get the press's attention. Because, you know, here are some of the wealthiest women in America standing alongside some of the poorest. So it was interesting, but it was all, you know, it's a it's easy all to also to over romanticize it because the this alliance was rather short-lived. You know, the the women were sympathetic to improving wages and conditions, but they were were not necessarily, you know, the first to to rush towards wanting the shift in power or wanting to embrace that the the women were asking for demands for unions and and greater control of their workplaces. And so, you know, the the strikes really, you know, had uh was varied in its in people's um support of it, but it also exposed a much larger debate about class and gender and and the meaning of reform back then, which were all sort of issues percolating that kind of came to a head with the fire.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. And it's so it's so interesting, yeah, what you were saying there about sort of wealthy women who are kind of high profile in society who are sort of somewhat surprisingly in support, at least up to a point, of the the striking workers. And I I wonder, I mean, you we've seen this in other times through history where if there are kind of multiple competing identities that can bind people together or motivate their philanthropy, actually it results in sort of odd uh outcomes. So the fact that they are women and there's a kind of gender-based shared identity, and they you kind of associate with these women means that they want to support them, even if you know they would be very unlikely to support male strikers, for instance, uh along the same lines. Um I think that's really fascinating. Um, I just wanted uh maybe let's let's come at this point to the fire itself. So I think we've kind of set the scene in terms of you know the fact that this uh factory, the triangle shirtwaist was something that was already kind of the center of debate and and kind of you know differing points of view, and then this fire happens. Um, what are the actual kind of circumstances of the fire itself?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I think you know, that maybe to paint a little bit of a picture. So the we're talking about a um uh a 10-story building um right next to Washington Square Park, which is sort of in the lower middle part of Manhattan. And the top three floors of that building were were home to a a company called the Triangle Waste Company, which was a company that made shirt waists, and um which is a popular women's women's blouse of the era. And most of the workers in that factory were um Jewish and Italian immigrant women. And the there was a cigarette that was placed in a waste bin on the eighth floor, and all the workers on the ninth floor were were trapped basically because there was a door that was blocked, and we know most likely it was locked by the factory owners because they would lock these doors so that the women couldn't take any kind of bathroom breaks during the day. It was, you know, it was a place of of trying to increase production at all costs. And um and tragically, because they couldn't escape, about 146 people died, um, 123 of which were um young women, mostly in their teens and early 20s. It was such a terrible moment in the history of New York, its greatest industrial disaster in its history. But it was so frustrating because of all these strikes and all these warnings that had come beforehand for years, saying that if something wasn't going to happen, that this, you know, that a tragedy like this would strike. And there was a, you know, a funeral march of almost half a million people in New York after this fire, which was um, you know, about almost 200,000 people marching and another 200 to 300,000 people witnessing it on the sidewalks of Fifth Avenue, which is, you know, about one in four people living in Manhattan at that time. It was um such a the the funeral march itself was such a spectacle. And and you know, workers were refusing to return to work, which was freezing what was by far New York's biggest industry. The garment industry was the backbone of New York's economy back then. And so, you know, the fire was really this galvanizing moment for the city. And the way that the typical histories of this event go is that, you know, this was then a moment that that awakened the consciences of New Yorkers to the sort of the plight of the Lower East Side immigrants, um, and that it brought this, you know, new uh generation of labor reform to the country. And that story is true, you know. I think that narrative of tragedy to reform is true. In the US, the fact that we have any kind of fire exit sign, for instance, in in any building can be traced to this fire. That was the uh the reform that came out of this event is the reason we have fire exit signs in buildings and and so many other worker safety protections. But, you know, the truth is that if you if you follow the donation money, which is what I do in the book, then you realize it's a much bigger story here because that money didn't go to you know the the workers of the Lower East Side who are who are calling for for support. It went to a handful of charities who had their own visions for for a different kind of New York.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And that's the bit of the story I really want to come on to now. Just before we do, just to say, I think you've mentioned there about the impact that the fire had in terms of wider reforms and things around sort of fire safety. But but it just picking up on one other element of the story itself, which felt important to me, is that the the actual response to the fire itself in terms of the court case that subsequently happened, in as you tell in the book, there's a ruling um by the court that the factory owners aren't actually themselves culpable for the fire. Was that a sort of important part of the story? And what was the public reaction to that verdict?
SPEAKER_01I mean, yes, uh it's a great question. The I think the I mean the short answer is that they got alpha on a loophole. So they um, you know, the the factory owners were quite wealthy individuals and they hired this um kind of celebrity lawyer at the time who was really able to kind of spin this this story with the jurists that that if they couldn't say with absolute certainty that, you know, on this day the the two factory owners, uh Max and and Isaac, that they had personally locked that door, then they couldn't possibly vote guilty. That was sort of the the framing that they were given. And so, you know, the a lot of the jurists said they couldn't say with absolute certainty that they happened, you know, there was no video evidence or anything like that, and so they they voted not guilty, and so they got off without without any punishment, really. And to be honest, they lost a little civil suit, but they made way more money in fire insurance um money from it. So they the book kind of gives a breakdown of how much money they actually earned per victim. Um, but it was an extraordinary amount. And you know, they opened up another factory three days after this fire, too, um, still without fire safety protections. So it goes to show, you know, I'm trying not to villainize anybody in this book. It's a book with that tries to center nuance, but but these are some of the facts. It was a lot of lessons not learned. And so, yeah, and so I would say for the the public was very upset, and even the Times was upset. And the interesting bit about it for me is that, you know, we can't know for sure, for instance, that story that I talked about at the beginning about Ox going and finding that New Yorker in need on Christmas of 1911. We can't say for sure that that didn't happen. But what we can say is that on that very week was the week of the triangle fire verdict. Um, that was the week where um New York and the Times particularly was in complete shock at the fact that the the court system did not find them guilty. Because for for months beforehand, the Times had said, you know, let's not organize, let's not get too upset, let's trust the the institutions of this country, let's trust the courts that justice will be served there, and it it wasn't. And so, you know, even the Times at that point was was sort of publishing that this isn't this isn't a good thing for the country, and um and people are upset.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, absolutely. I think that's really important, and leads on to what you were sort of talking about or starting to talk about before, I think, which is this sense that in a way there's a version of this story where philanthropy or charity was proposed as the response, you know, the appropriate response to the fire. And if that philanthropy had been focused on genuinely helping or supporting those who have been affected by the fire and the kind of the immigrant communities um and the workers, maybe that would be a more positive version. But actually, an important element of this story is that's not the conception of charity that we're talking about. Um and and what's really uh important here is and this brought it onto something that I have kind of read about before, so I was very excited to see this, which is the idea of scientific charity, which you know anyone listening who's not aware of it might sort of not know this was a really big and powerful idea at the certainly in the early 20th century in the US, but also kind of in the UK and other places. Can you say a bit about what this conception of scientific charity was and kind of how widespread it was at the time we're talking about?
SPEAKER_01Yes, exactly. And when I say in this conversation, when I'm saying charity or new charity, that's exactly what we're referring to, which this notion of scientific charity, um, as it was called back then. And it was um, as you say too, it was first sort of established in um in Europe and a lot of the ideas from the UK, and a lot of those ideas then came over and took a unique shape a unique shape in the US. Um and I'd say that at the time of the fire, it was a movement that was had been struggling in the previous decades to sort of gain any traction. Um it was always sort of in search of a big moment, a bigger stage, and and that's what the fire provided it. That's why it was such a turning point in the history of that movement in the country and in it gaining power. Um, but I'd say to paint, you know, a bit of a picture too, that charity was really at you know, in transition. It was a world in transition at the start of the progressive era. For generations, it had been something that was tended to be personal and local. You gave through your church, you know, your synagogue, or maybe your union, but you tended to know the people you were giving your money to. And then this new idea arrived, of course, at the turn of the 20th century, which was called scientific charity. And the premise was pretty simple. Um, when it comes to charitable giving, it was, you know, don't trust your emotions, you should trust the experts. Their idea was that the field of charity should be um professionalized, it should be investigative. These people wanted to sort of study poor families, you know, determine their needs, and distinguish the the worthy from the unworthy poor. And in doing so, they promised, you know, wealthy New Yorkers that their donations wouldn't be wasted, that this would be the most sort of cost-effective use of your money in creating positive change. And one organization called the New York Church the New York Charity Organization Society was at the center of this scientific charity movement. Um, and they were the most sort of vocal and most powerful player for that movement, not just in New York, but in the country. And there's a building that sort of is a central focus in the book because they they helped give it not just an ideological home, but a physical home, in this building called the United Charities Building, which is um still in New York. It's on Park Avenue, and you can still see United Charities Building sort of on an arch on one of the sides of the building. And it's this very, you know, important seeming structure made with great arches, you know, and limestone. And um, while the charity organization society had most of the offices in that building, they also invited all the other states' major charities to put their headquarters there. And so you had in one place, you know, all of the most powerful um leaders of the scientific charity movement, um, all in one building. And this building had, you know, a library of social reform books. It was actually in that building where you had the very first school for social work um in the U.S. It was a summer program that was created by the charity organization society before eventually moving to Columbia as sort of a curriculum program, um, although still it was led by a man named Edward Devine, who's who's a key figure in the book and who was um sort of the general secretary of the charity organization society. So he had a foot in both worlds, which helped also give this movement a perception that it was was indeed academically based or scientifically based. And, you know, the point of talking about this building, I think, is that um charities, it was, you know, symbolic of what they were trying to tell the rest of New York charity had become. That it was um that it was no longer happening in the gilded age living rooms of the wealthy. Um it was now a scientific and serious, formidable enterprise with bold ideas, you know, real books, science, and even this big, important building. And I'd say even the location too had some symbolic meaning because there was previously a church in that location and they had demolished the church and then built the building on top. And that's that's similar to the change in authority that they were trying to convince New Yorkers of at the time. They were traveling to churches, you know, uh across the city to ask pastors and rabbis to encourage their congregations to stop giving to the churches and instead give to this new um crop of professional philanthropy and professional um charities. And I would just say that, you know, the problem was that before the fire, people didn't really understand what they were talking about. You know, they were backed by some of the richest men in New York, like JP Morgan was their treasurer, this man named Jacob Schiff um was their vice pre vice president, and these were two of the wealthiest men in the city. So a lot of New Yorkers were like, you know, why do they need our money? Um the president of the charity organization charity organization society was a man named Robert DeForest, whose grandfather created the New York Stock Exchange. So these were such powerful people. So, you know, why did they need an average New Yorker's money? Nobody really got it. And then, of course, the fire came along and changed everything because suddenly the city felt deep guilt and they wanted to do something. And the question became, you know, who would receive that generosity? Would it go to the unions and the families of the workers, who they were told are these, you know, radical anarchists who are trying to sow discord in the country, or would they give to these new professional charities that were saying, you know, don't trust your emotions, trust the experts. They were saying we have the buildings, the schools, the science to help ensure that that your money will be well spent. And and the Times, of course, made that choice even more simple by just telling them this is the right way for your money. And so um, so yeah, so that was so it was very much an idea in search of a bigger stage, and that bigger stage came with the fire.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. And I'm I'm sure talking a little bit about some of the lessons from this particular story or just generally lessons from history, but I'm sure people who work in philanthropy now listening to what you're saying, so much of that must sound familiar because I think so many of the elements actually that form the professionalized world of philanthropy today and the way in which money, you know, decisions are made about how money is allocated, actually comes from that sort of template that was established by scientific philanthropy, even if we've got rid of some of the sort of less tasteful elements of it. Um but it's you know that kind of dominant idea of a scientific approach, professionalized organizations, uh, people kind of who are given the job of managing philanthropic resources and using their expertise to do that, all of that comes from this kind of thinking. And as you say, it wasn't necessarily a given by by any means that this was going to be the case, and it kind of took this particular moment for it to happen, which I think is so interesting. Um in terms of how that played into the creation of the the 100 Needious Cases um campaign that the New York Times uh launched, was this something that the Adolf Ox himself was kind of was he already part of this thinking or aware of it, or was it the more that at this point where he started thinking, actually we need a response to this this fire and charity feels like the appropriate one? Would he already have been thinking in terms of this scientific charity, or would that have sort of come at that moment for him?
SPEAKER_01I mean, it's a it's a great question. I think, and this is one of those those pieces that is really hard to know with absolute certainty, um, because he never there's no record of his exact thinking um on this. But I think it's um, you know, when I think about it as as uh, you know, was this like a business decision or was this really something that was motivated by his own morals or his own religious positioning? And I think it's it was it was absolutely both because they both reinforced one another. So I mean his his beliefs around charity and his business interests were not at all in conflict. And I wouldn't say that I would assume that that Ox was insincere either in believing that charity could do good. I think that's why I so appreciate your the connections that you were making with it today. I think there was there was a real belief back then that that this was the right approach, um, that it was being led by you know some of the you know the most powerful and and so I think hence people thought the most smart people in the country. And there was a belief that that it was that its purpose was to do good and that that was what everybody was working towards. But there's the other side of the story, you know, that I just mentioned, which is that, uh which is unavoidable, which was that Ox, you know, had acquired the New York Times um with a very deliberate business strategy. And and he wanted to, you know, not just compete for the largest readership. He was never interested in in the readers of the Lower East Side who were the workers. Um he wanted to really be the paper that the wealthiest families of New York turned to towards to understand the events of the day and um how they respond to them. And one of the most important people back then was this man named Jacob Schiff, who was the powerful financier and philanthropist who helped Ox ultimately purchase the Times and was who was somebody who Ox looked to as a father figure in his own words. And at the time of the Triangle Fire, you know, Ox owed Schiff also, you know, hundreds of thousands of dollars because he was behind, you know, the the New Times building and so many of other Ox's efforts. Schiff had also kind of advanced himself at the time of the fire as the person who was, and the mayor of New York also advanced Jacob Schiff as the the sort of representative of charity for the entire city. And so his reputation was on the line as well at the time of this fire. And so, you know, by backing Schiff and telling actually Times readers to send their money directly to Schiff into his charity, which we were just talking about, the charity organization society, he was supporting his closest ally and and friend and financier as well. Um and so it was um, you know, I don't know how precisely we can say Ox's decision was motivated by, you know, personal conviction that this was the best approach or business calculation. But, you know, you could see that the charitable response really served both. And I think that's why, you know, it also was able to take off so quickly because it it allowed it was a comfortable response to a really uncomfortable uh tragedy.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. And and one of the key aspects of you already mentioned there about the sort of the scientific charity approach is this idea that the responsibility of the donor helped by these this kind of new breed of professionalized uh experts is to give effectively and and not give to the wrong people. And usually it's based on some sort of distinction between those that are deserving and those that are undeserving. Um, and we kind of see that in the aftermath of um of the the triangle uh factory disaster. And I was really struck actually just my awareness of kind of other responses to historical disasters, it felt like there were echoes because it's certainly something we saw here in the UK when you look at the history of the response to the Titanic tragedy, for instance, or some of the responses to kind of mining disasters, you get these similar stories where there's a kind of upsurge of a desire to do something charitable, and then that gets filtered through, oh, but we we want to make sure it only goes to the deserving cases, and so it becomes very judgmental, um, and you know, feels very much more problematic. And I guess the the kind of the logical extreme of that, which you touch on in the book, and and which is kind of I think something recognized more broadly about the history of scientific philanthropy, is that that initial desire to do good and to do it in the most effective and rational way possible can end up becoming problematic and have sort of very problematic unintended consequences when combined with other ideas. And and certainly in the book you you have a chapter sort of um called Modern Charity's First Big Idea. Um, and maybe you could say a bit about what that big idea is, because it's certainly a problematic one that I think people will have heard of.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean it unfortunately that's the darker side of the history, which is the you know, one of its big um uh its big galvanizing ideas was around eugenics. Um and and I would say too, just kind of if I if I can, just kind of touch on something that you said also, and then it can go into a little bit about you know why eugenics was was so um helpful to the the sort of vision that these charities had for New York. Um but I think uh one of the the parts of this tragedy that really people had didn't understand um before was that that part of you know what actually happened to the money after the fire. And because a lot of the which I think is a lot of how other people respond to tragedies, like you said, which is that when you give, that maybe the story ends there that you gave. And um and there's not a lot of follow-up of what happened to that money, you know, how was it used, um, and we we sort of forget about that the years down the line. And in the the case of the Triangle Fire, it you know, it raised over a hundred thousand dollars for the charity organization society and a couple other charities that were supporting them, um, which was by far the most money you know raised in a single charity campaign in the country's history to that point. And but But the tragedy is that, you know, because of this sort of architecture of scientific charity, um, they didn't just give that money, you know, equitably to the people of the Lower East Side. They decided to, you know, study which families really needed it. And they determined that some of these families were so poor already that you know the loss of their sort of their primary money uh breadwinner wasn't actually going to make them that much poorer. So they gave a lot of families $50. And they kept about a quarter of the money, over $20,000, to put towards other um relief work efforts. And they didn't actually give any get didn't actually give that money to any of the organizations on the lower east side. Um and so this is something that I think even back then, I mean, that was something I learned in just looking at the annual reports. So it wasn't super it wasn't buried. And I it helped it makes me wonder if people would have even been upset about it back then because I think they were so trusting that that if these organizations said that they weren't worthy of charity, then they must not have been. But if we know, you know, going into the book really goes into these homes in the Lower East Side to see what it was like. And that's a part of the story that also doesn't really get told because this sort of shift in authority towards charities, you know, meant something very different if you were living um in the tenements of the Lower East Side. It meant strangers were suddenly walking into your homes, you know, uninvited. Um they were asking you these deeply intimate questions to try to understand if you were worthy or not worthy of aid. And if you were born out of wedlock, for instance, back then you were considered not worthy of aid, so you wouldn't get any charity money. The these um institutions then also, you know, if they thought you were not a contributing member to society, um, I found evidence that they reported you for deportations. And this was before, you know, all the big, you know, immigration restriction laws that we had in the 1920s. If they thought you were mentally unwell, you were forced institutionalized against your will. Um you were put in mental health institutions. They forced sterilized unknown unknown thousands of New Yorkers, um, so they couldn't procreate. And this was led by these charities, by the charity organization, society, and and the other big scientific charities in that United Charities building. And so that's a legacy that I think um we really haven't dealt with um in this country. And I think maybe that you
unknownknow,
SPEAKER_01philanthropy as a whole really hasn't dealt with some of these um these really un uh terrible consequences of some of its early founders. And you know, it kind of it connects with a a big reason for a lot of that work is because it connects with eugenics, which was that that big idea that you were referring to. Because you know, scientific charity was really built around the idea that that poverty and other social problems could be studied, classified, you know, treated um by trained experts. Rather than, you know, simply giving money to people in need, charity workers really believed that they should be investigating um these issues. And eugenics fit so well into that worldview because eugenicists claimed, you know, falsely that poverty, criminality, and other social problems were inherited problems. And for some of New York's leading charity officials, you know, that offered what appeared to be a scientific explanation for why certain people remained poor and why certain immigrants in the U.S. were a threat to sort of American society. So instead of you know simply asking how to help people escape poverty, these organizations were were increasingly asking how to prevent certain kinds of people from entering the country, how to prevent them from having children, um, how to prevent them from participating in society. And they used really, you know, um terrible terminology in you know today about uh you know about those issues. And this was all you know in front page newsletters of these charities. It wasn't something they were secretly doing. On their annual reports, eugenics is there as a an item of you know a part of their budget. And so this was right, you know, out there in the open. It wasn't a theoretical thing. And I think the last thing I'd say, you know, there's a uh moment in the book in 1914 where one of the city's leading charity officials, um, a man named Homer Folks, is enthusiastically celebrating in his sort of monthly um newsletter editorial that eugenics is in the air when describing the atmosphere of the United Charities building that spring. And, you know, it just goes to show how much excitement there was about this idea. And I think that's what makes this history so important, because you know, under the banner of scientific progress, this idea of modern charity established to to help the poor um become became at you know powerful advocates for policies that denied them some of the most, you know, vulnerable people their basic rights. Um and that's a that's a piece of this history I think we really haven't grappled with yet.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, agreed. And I think it's it's fascinating and really adds to, I think, some of the other elements of the story that have been been told in certain places, although, as you say, not not as widespread as you would hope about the role that some of the big progressive funders and donors of of certainly of the early 20th century played in kind of propagating the ideas of of eugenics, often, as you say, in plain sight, because they didn't feel the need to be embarrassed about it. Um, and I think to me there is yeah, there is a really important lesson for philanthropy today about what happens when you kind of prioritize rationality or an idea of effectiveness at all costs over any sort of notion of humanity. Uh, and I think it's always, you know, it's important to be kind of reminded about that and to take lessons from history. But then I guess it it also feels unfortunately very timely because there might have been a point, you know, a decade or two ago when we thought eugenics was something that was consigned to the past and we could read a history like this and think, you know, isn't it terrible that that happened? I think unfortunately, you know, some of those ideas feel as though they are coming back to the fore in new guises and kind of ideas that we should um pick and choose who should be able to procreate or kind of you know prioritize certain genetic groups at the uh for for the benefit of humanity or in the interests of some kind of claimed public good, or unfortunately things that we're seeing again today. So it feels um like an extremely timely warning, as I say. And maybe that brings me to the kind of wider question I'd really love to ask you, which is is about that that idea that we can kind of read these specific histories of of kind of events and about philanthropy and take lessons from them. I mean, I I feel like we can, I think, if it's done in the right way, and I spent a lot of my time reading this stuff, so I believe that. But but what value do you think kind of taking that historical perspective can bring, particularly for people who are working in or thinking about philanthropy today?
SPEAKER_01I love this question. Um, and I mean it's a big reason why I I love a lot of your work as well. And I I, you know, I personally think there should be a historian at every philanthropic institution. And, you know, I think this is something I could talk about for a long time, but to be succinct, I think one of the, I would say one of the most valuable things history can do, I I, in my opinion, is help us question the some assumptions we've inherited, especially the ones that have become so you know familiar that we we no longer think to question them. So for people working in in philanthropy, I think that means, um, as you were saying, understanding the ideas, values, and and sometimes the prejudices of the people who built many of the institutions we recognize and and often admire today. I think it also means remembering that the founders of a lot of these institutions were not necessarily the first people doing this work. You know, they weren't the first people wanting to make the world a better place, um, and not even the people with the best ideas. You know, long before modern philanthropy became a professional field, immigrant communities, labor unions, you know, neighborhood associations were developing their own ways of helping one another confront injustice. And one of the things my this book, I think, shows is that certain approaches to social change become dominant, not necess necessarily because they were the most effective, you know, or the most just, but because they had the greatest financial and institutional backing. So I think one of the, you know, the things history encourages us to ask is not not only, I guess, you know, what we've inherited, but what alternatives were pushed aside along the way, um, and what might we learn from that today. Um, you know, there's one, there's one issue. I hate to like narrow things down to one issue, but one thing that I'm I'm thinking about right now, and I've been thinking about recently, which I'd love to discuss with you in more detail um sometime, is that it's been revealing to me just how much, how distant philanthropy, for instance, is from organized labor work, even though both are concerned with issues of poverty and you know inequality and improving people's lives, they they both remain so distant from one another. And in the book, I highlight on many instances of where some of these tensions were born, but it still surprises me how persistent they are. You know, mainstream philanthropy, at least in the US, um, remains very reluctant to have anything to do with unions and worker organizing, often kind of viewing it as something, you know, fundamentally different from charity work. And I think that's telling perhaps because it it reveals how I think resistant some forms of philanthropy are to actually advocating for shifts in power. So there can be a lot of talk about wanting to advocate for shifts in power, but you know, in the spaces where there's real advan movements being made to try to enforce that, often we don't see philanthropy as sort of a leading actor. And it's it just raises me a question that I think I think about a lot, which is, you know, why do we often discuss philanthropy as a vehicle for social change without including organized labor in that conversation? And I think that's something that this book provides some insights around, but of course not an answer. Um, but it's interesting.
SPEAKER_00It is absolutely fascinating, and I would l love to talk about that more maybe at another time. But I think you're it was something that came across to me in the book as well. It was one of the things that left me with was this was that sense of the the relationship between organized labour and philanthropy. And and I guess that sort of that feeling that we're forced into a choice between justice on the one hand and and kind of charity on the other. And actually, you know, increasingly I think people within the philanthropy world now are sort of starting to question whether it needs to be that clear-cut and whether you can use philanthropy as a tool itself to to further kind of ends of justice, but what that looks like, and maybe you do start to come back more towards well, we need to, you know, uh fund things like organized labour and things that will kind of result in fundamental change. But as you say, it's still not anywhere near as widespread as you as you might think. And and I was just gonna say as well, on the you know, in terms of the lessons that we take from this, I think um questioning those assumptions that we have about you know why we do things the way we do and the structures and the norms that we have in philanthropy is is so important. And you know, I've thought that for a long time around the history of scientific charity and its links to things like um eugenics and what it tells us about kind of the way in which we approach philanthropy today. But but this book, I think I just wanted to say thank you because it brought a whole new kind of range of angles to that that I wasn't aware of, and particularly that sense that, you know, I I think maybe I thought that the story of the the spread of the ideas of scientific charity was kind of inevitable, but I think being reminded that like so many other stories, it did also turn on quite specific contextual factors and it might have gone in a very different direction. Um, there's a really important reminder about that contingency um that we often find when we look at history. So uh I just want to we're coming up on the end of the hour, David, and I could I could keep you talking for for ages more because I'm really enjoying uh just sort of digging into this stuff. Um, but I just wanted before I let you go, just to ask you kind of what your plans are next for the book. Um, you know, if you've been out and about talking to people so far, what the response has been and and what your plans are.
SPEAKER_01Thank you so much. So this has been such a joy for me. Um yeah, I it's a great question. I I don't know this this project took so long, you know, over over a decade. So it's I think in the in the world of uh book writing, everybody says you should put your next proposal out there pretty soon, but um I still feel a long way away from that. So I think I'm I'm still um uh I've been really grateful to to engage with um people like yourself in these kind of conversations. Um when I wrote the book, I didn't have a you know an argument of of its sort of key lessons, I think, for for philanthropy or labor or or journalism. And so um I tried to just tell the story as as faithfully as I could to the historical record. And so so now I'm just uh uh I'm I'm trying to stay true to those sources and and honor that the time that that people shared with me in interviews as well, and and trying to to open up this book to hopefully make make it useful in some ways. And so I I've really enjoyed that process so far. You know, I've spoken in pretty varied uh climate, uh varied environments, and I've had people who have had you know direct connections with this fire kind of come up to me who are you know descendants of, I mean, we talked about the lawyer, the a granddaughter of the lawyer came up to me and um said, you know, I'm on the wrong side of this history, but um, but um, but still very interested in it. And you know, person who who worked the elevators in that building came up to me recently. And so a lot of people would be great to to have talked to before finishing the book, but still, you know, great to to be making these connections. And um, so yeah, so right now I think this is a an event that's that's become a pretty big part of my life, and so I'm I'm still um just grateful to have these kind of conversations. And if anybody who's listening also would like to talk about this, whether it's within the you know the realm of of philanthropy and charity or just the historical you know event, I'd be very happy to do that. It's um uh it's something that I I I'm enjoying and having a lot of meaning in.
SPEAKER_00Great, yeah. Well, absolutely, and and certainly I'll put links in the show notes to places where people can find the book, and I you know thoroughly recommend that people go away and get a copy and read it because it's really fascinating story. I mean, we've touched on lots of elements here, but there's loads more uh in there to for people to get their teeth into. Um just remains to say thanks ever so much for finding some time to come on the podcast and talk about it. Um, it'd be really great to hear about it and wish you all the best in the future.
SPEAKER_01Thank you, thank you so much. No, likewise, thank you.
SPEAKER_00Okay, great. Well, my thanks again to David for coming on the podcast. Um, it was really great to have a chance to hear from him about his book, um, which I thoroughly recommend uh that you go and read if you've got even a passing interest in the history of philanthropy. And I'll put links in the show notes to places where you can get hold of uh a copy of that. If you're interested in the history of philanthropy or just philanthropy and civil society more broadly, do check out the website at whyphilanthropymatters.com. Lots of things there about the history of philanthropy, but also about kind of current practice and what might happen in the future. Lots of uh all of the back episodes of this podcast, lots of news updates. You can find an archive of the monthly newsletter I do, you can find out how you can sign up for that. Uh, you can get in touch with me if you like. Uh, if you've got thoughts on the podcast in terms of things we could cover or people that I could speak to in future. Um, if you like the podcast and you think other people might like it as well, uh, do give a recommendation either you know by word of mouth, um, which goes a long way, or you can leave us a nice review or rate it wherever it is that you get your podcasts. That also helps bumping us up the algorithm. Um, other than that, it just remains to say thanks ever so much for listening, and I will see you next time. Bye.